Are Altered Art Cards Legal in MTG?
Magic: The Gathering (MTG) has been a popular trading card game since its inception in 1993. Players collect, trade, and play with cards featuring unique art and design, creating a vibrant and diverse community. However, as the game has grown, some players have taken it upon themselves to alter the art on their cards. The question on many players’ minds is: Are altered art cards legal in MTG?
Understanding the Legalities
The legality of altered art cards in MTG is a complex issue that depends on several factors. Firstly, it is essential to distinguish between “artwork” and “card.” The artwork on a Magic card is protected by copyright laws, while the card itself is a collectible item.
Legal Implications of Altering Artwork
When a player alters the artwork on a Magic card, they are infringing on the copyright of the original artist. This action can lead to legal consequences, including fines and the potential seizure of the altered cards. Wizards of the Coast, the company behind MTG, has been known to enforce its copyright by taking action against players who alter their cards.
Legal Implications of Altering Cards
On the other hand, altering the card itself, such as adding stickers or markers to the card’s surface, is generally considered legal. This is because the card is a physical object that can be modified without affecting the original artwork. However, players should be cautious not to damage the card in a way that would render it unplayable or unsellable.
Community Perspectives
The legality of altered art cards in MTG has sparked a debate within the community. Some players argue that as long as the original artwork remains intact, altering the card is a form of personal expression and should be allowed. Others believe that any modification of the card, including the artwork, is a violation of copyright laws and should be prohibited.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while altering the artwork on a Magic: The Gathering card is a clear violation of copyright laws, altering the card itself is generally considered legal. Players should exercise caution when modifying their cards to avoid potential legal issues. Ultimately, the decision to alter a card is a personal choice, but it is essential to understand the potential consequences before proceeding.
